SPACE, the final frontier. These are the voyages of the Star Ship Enterprise. Its continuing mission to explore strange new worlds, to seek out new life and new civilizations, to boldly go where no one has gone before.
Ever since the first episode of the Star Trek sci-fi series where Captain James T. Kirk of the Star Ship USS Enterprise blasts across the universe in search of new life, I have been completely mesmerised and fascinated with space and its infinite possibilities.
I was awed to read about the first man in space, the first man on the moon and the first space station. Its like a whole new world out there. Full of opportunities, possibilities and a whole new set of rules. It just gets more interesting and exciting.
Its common knowledge that the United States and Russia rule the upper atmosphere and space areas. And they have been the predominant powers in inner and outer space for well over half a century now.
In October 2003, China launched her first piloted space flight into earth's orbit. These were exciting times. A developing country had broken through into the space club.
This is what the Times of India editorial had to say about the launch.
"It would be better to call it China's Late Creep Forward, given that Beijing is attempting to showcase a four-decade-old technology....If this is China's idea of arriving, then it's come at a time when the other two spacefaring nations have left it light years behind."
And this is what the BBC had to say.
"...it does spell out to the world that China has the know-how and financial clout to put a crew into space."
Anyways, my fascination with space exploration came to a harsh test last week. I was at a lunch with my entire office team. It was a nice Italian place a few blocks from my office. It was quite a big group and me along with three other colleagues were seated at the end of the table which pretty much gave us the space to get into a private group conversation.
We were as usual discussing the current happenings in the world. Our chief discussion being the earthquake in South Asia. The topics then turned towards developmental issues, politics and ofcourse whatever was going on with the Katrina victims.
And then I passed an innocuous comment on China's second space launch and how India now needs to compete and get its act together.
And that was the last time we had a sober and civil conversation.
Immediately people took sides. I was accused of wanting to waste India's precious capital on a wasteful expense such as space exploration.
I was aghast. How could someone say something like that. For me, space exploration is by default in India's list of To Do's. It never struck me, that there would be people who would look at something so adventurous as this to be a waste of money. How un-scientific and non-visionary could one get !?
I was not going to give in so easily. And fortunately for me, one other colleague in the group was on my side. And we happily closed ranks to trounce the opposers.
If the United Kingdom, Spain and Portugal had thought of sea exploration in the same way then would the UK have become the largest and most powerful empire on earth ever, I asked.
In the United States, the commercial spin-offs from the defence and space industry into the civilian areas is immense. Should'nt we too explore the positive effects of this synergy, I reasoned.
In the 1970's and 80's when India began its space program with the launch of its satellites into space, a crowd of people with similar beliefs and ideas called it a wasteful expenditure for a poor country like India where people could'nt even afford one meal a day. But today, nobody questions India's need to launch satellites into space, beamed my colleague.
Anyways, said he, India should'nt have gone Nuclear if at all this logic were applied.
Those are defence issues and India needs to defend her people, was the return volley.
What people, I questioned. The very same people who cannot afford a days meal, who dont have a roof over their head, who dont have clean drinking water or proper sanitation ? Are you saying we should build a mammoth arsenal to defend people who are dying of hunger, I blasted back.
I got an eye to eye glare for this remark, followed by a, "Do you think I am stupid ?", question. I gulped hard, smiled and beat a hasty retreat. Not because my point was off the mark, but because the question was from my client !!
I had boldly gone where probably no consultant had gone before !!
However, having made my point, I decided not to press further. The rest of the conversation was more between him and my other colleague. I was a passive listener and my only participation in the conversation were frowns, head nodes and smiles. That was good enough for me.
Anyways, my client called me into his office a couple of days back and to my surprise said he had been thinking about what I had said about space exploration a while ago.
And guess what, he agreed with me !!
18 comments:
I read somewhere (maybe Rajeev Srinivasan's articles in Rediff) that to have your bread and butter in peace, you first need to defend yourself from marauders and that is why India needs a minimum deterrance whether be it space or military. In fact, our whole poverty of now (which was non-existent before the Mughals/British invaded/occupied/colonized us) was due to our history of receiving deceitful people with a peck on the cheek while they had a dagger in their cloak which theu then used to carve us out.
I agree with you Eswar, but not as fast and tough as you are. May be like your client, a little slowly. Even during the discussion to enter into to space and satellite program, Periyar supported the program but Rajaji commented that it is criminal waste of people money. Always people have different opinions.
Thennavan...your comment is absolutely correct. India needs to have an wholesome view of supreme national interest and that does not end with just territorial defence alone.
sunday thots...I am surprised to learn that Rajaji opposed space exploration. At the sametime I am glad to hear that Periyar had the foresight to understand the strategic need to have a vibrant space program if at all india wants to become a super power.
Dude you are confusing me...You support one scientific exploration and speak againt another.
I feel that India decision to go nuclear helped us to become self reliant during the post nuclear economic slumps.
Regarding space exploration, India still needs to do lot of homework. I need we still need to build the economy capable of taking such a large expenditure.
like all kids i 2 wanted 2 be a spaceman...esp after reading the tintin comic explorers on the moon..i also used 2 love the fantastic 4 when it used 2 come on d cartoon network.btw have u heard this conspiracy theory abt the us moon landing being a hoax?
Mukund and Eshwar
I agree with both of your points.
Eswar: I was reading you blog, interesting.
This is what I feel - Places like SHAR [Sriharikota], even Thumba [trivandrum] are geographically suited for commerical satellite launches. Why? we can have an offline discussion.
We might soon compete with French Guyana, where most satellite are done , we just need to build a payload that carries it to the space, Russia is not giving us the cryogenic fundas, some other “top” powers are preventing it.
Bottom line, launching commercial satellite is a lucrative business, if we could raise some capital and revenue using space technology we can use it in other areas for development. This can come to reality only if we have sane and stable space research organization, luckily we have one. And our president is part of it, “a technical part”, not for just name sake
Abul Kalam along with 4 others visited our NASA Goddard [near the sivavishnu temple, dc] about 30 years ago to get the basics.
It is an ongoing process. We will soon prosper.
Rags...you misunderstood me. I do support the tests. I was merely trying to bring out the illogic of the opposing groups reasons.
Siddharth...yes I have read about the lunar landing conspiracy theory !! Very innovative !
Sriks...glad to know that were are well on the way to becoming a spacefaring nation, soon.
Eshwar,
Space exploration is required just for the simple reason because cutting edge technology is dependent on it. Imagine just designing something that can take you to space would make you capable of acheiving numerous things. Put satellites into orbit (better communication), people often forget that satellites are great for remote sensing, something that we forget to address when we defend our space program. India should look at tapping that kind of technology. A mission to moon might not necessarily be top priority but India surely should take giant strides at developing a space program that can atleast be instrumental at setting up a space station. It is sad that India is not even represented in the international space station. The space station is a hub for cutting edge technological advancement and research. I do think that we were on the right track when we launched the PSLV (polar satellite launch vehicle), even though it was a failure it wasnt a complete failure. It did not acheieve the required altitude but it was a success of sorts because india for the first time tried solid fuel propulsion and a payload weighing around 1 tonne. With limited funds and exposure india surely has done well in its space ventures. It is hard to predict where this will take us. We have to take up bold ventures like china for the advancement of our space ventures or atleast team up with other countries that already have the expertise. People will surely moan and groan at how wasteful space research is and the argument will go on, but it would be easy to convince them if you just threw in the advantages of what space research offers them. It is just ignorance that makes them speak that way,they simply need to be educated!
Robbie...I agree. Btw where you refering to the GSLV ?
yeah eshwar,
I was referring to the geo synchronus launch vehicle and not the PSLV. I jumbled up the jargon in my hurry to put in my comment:P
thanks for correcting me though
space exploration is the way to go, its necessary, its the next frontier and india just cant afford to miss the bus. but the essential question is how important is it?? its a necessity, but out of indias huge list of necessities, where does it feature? these are the questions which need to be asked
Eshwar
Happy Deepavali man.
Happy Deepavali Eshwar :-)
Well as Thennavan pointed out Rajeev's article, you can't wait for everything to be in order, before you can start working on advancement in technology.
The return on investment, though not immediate, is very huge in the long run.
Client, Agrees ...hmmm :)
Happy diwali to all.
Arvi...thanks.
Eswar, don’t stay in the Space for so long time, come to earth and write some blogs. Please don’t disappoint your fans.
Post a Comment